Jump to content United Kingdom-English
HP.com United Kingdom home Products and Services Support and Drivers Solutions How to Buy
»  Contact HP
HP.com United Kingdom home
BladeSystem Community

Weekly comment

» 

BladeSystem Community

» Discussion Forum
» Highlight articles
» Complete library archive
» Feedback

Further info

» Discover the HP BladeSystem
» The Real Story about IBM's BladeCenter
» What the industry is saying
» BladeSystem Evaluation Centre
Talk to your peers
Content starts here

Understanding Solid State Drives (part three – power and cost)

text image Getting the best performance is no longer the only requirement for hardware. The power requirements and associated running costs are now replacing the traditional storage approach of cost per byte. Although a premium priced technology SSD can already show a saving over time.

Power

Unlike a traditional hard drive there are no moving parts inside an SSD. With no moving parts there is no need for much of the power used by hard drives. There are no platters to spin, no actuators to move and no heads to control.

A look around the specifications of hard drive vendors shows that the typical power usage for an SAS drive can be as high as 10W in active mode and around 4W when idle. High capacity SATA drives can use even more power although all the major hard drive vendors are reducing the power demand in each new generation of drives.

Hard drives draw power when idle for three reasons. The first is that stopping and starting drives is not power efficient. It is also a risk factor in that the more a drive stops and starts, the more the risk of failure increases. This is no different to stopping and starting the engine in a car. There is a drain on the battery as it provides a spark to ignite the fuel. For a brief moment the engine uses more revs than in idle mode just to start up.

The second reason is for access times. Users do not want to wait seconds for a drive to be powered up, brought online and their data to be recovered. Thirdly, data is rarely stored on a single drive inside the datacentre. We spread the data over drive arrays, which improve speed by making sure there are many more heads accessing the data. It also improves our risk, by using redundant technologies that allow us to recover from the failure of a drive.

The average power used by an SSD is 1W in active mode and .1W in idle mode. Most servers have a minimum of 2 hard drives installed. Depending on the generation and model of the existing hard drives in your server you should experience anything from 14W to 20W saving per server.

Cost

Such savings are significant especially when balanced over the lifecycle of the server. However the current costs make this a decision that cannot yet be based solely on the cost savings. For example, if you are paying around 15p per kWh then a saving of 20W per server over a 3 year period would equate to a saving of £78.84. Even if you double that amount due to the power savings of not having to cool the drives, you are still looking at around just £157.68 per server.

That sum is still less than the cost difference today, between traditional hard drives and SSD. However, that premium is continuing to fall and will continue to reduce as SSD approach commodity pricing in the next 12-24 months. This is the time most SSD vendors believe it will take to get manufacturing capacity online, and for the industry to adopt SSD as a mainstream storage technology.

But it is not just about the cost savings in servers. Every datacentre has large arrays of drives storing data. The type of data and the applications that create and consume it differ widely. We already use different storage technologies to deal with the different applications. With thousands of drives already running 24 x 7 x 365, reducing the power by up to 10W per drive is extremely attractive.

Unlike server arrays, storage arrays have a much longer shelf life. They can be in use for up to five years, which is the length of the manufacturers warranty. However, SSD are more resilient and could easily last a decade. This means that the extra cost of SSD when offset against the power saving over that period, makes them an affordable investment today.

Datacentre costs are not just about power and cooling. As the amount of power available to the datacentre continues to be restricted, while the demand for more compute power and storage continue to rocket upwards, there is a need to modify one to accommodate the other.

This is where SSD, especially in storage arrays, has a distinct advantage. There is no longer any need to make the SSD look like a hard drive. The current design assumes spinning disks and moving parts. With no need for moving parts, the only design limitations are fitting inside the enclosure, the data connection and the power connection. These latter two are defined by industry standards. But with no heat to dissipate, a 3U storage enclosure could conceivably hold many more times the number of drives than an enclosure today.

The massive reduction of power from moving away from hard drives to SSD – and the increased density – means that power and space are made available for servers and other components. For the datacentre, this means room to grow, instead of the need to invest in a new building and the migration of the datacentre.

While other savings can be measured in the hundreds, thousands and tens of thousands of pounds, not having to build a new datacentre and migrate systems is a saving that runs into the millions of pounds, most of it CapEx.

Capacity

The only real restriction on widespread take-up of SSD is the current capacities. At between 32GB and 128GB these drives fit well into the server and high speed drive markets. But to really become a storage technology they need to be pushing 512GB, 1TB or above. While such capacities have been demonstrated no vendor is will to put a price on a SSD capable of holding that much data.

Conclusion

SSD is a technology that is just coming to the datacentre. It will require a period of bedding down and prices need to drop a long way before it becomes a commodity technology. The potential savings it adds to those of low wattage processors, low power memory and more efficient power supplies offers mid to long term savings, that will not only offset increased power costs but also help fund several generations of system inside the datacentre itself.

RSS feed

» Sign up for HP BladeSystem RSS feed

Author’s Biography

Ian Murphy Industry observer Ian Murphy has been an IT Journalist for over 24 years. During that time he has written for the vast majority of UK IT titles including Computing, Computer Weekly, IT Pro and International Developer. As well as writing for publications, Ian has been a developer, systems administrator, support manager and trainer covering everything from mainframe technologies to embedded systems.
 

 

"Unlike a traditional hard drive there are no moving parts inside a SSD."

 

"It will require a period of bedding down and prices need to drop a long way before it becomes a commodity technology."
Printable version
Privacy statement Using this site means you accept its terms
© 2008 Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P.